« | »

More Alan Trammell and Some Good Reading

I took some heat for my last post on Tram when I said he should be given one more year. First off, I apologize about the error. They were 26-26 in two runs games, not in games decided by less then two runs. All I was trying to show here was one of many indicators that the Tigers have been “okay” in close games.

I guess the main reason why I think Tram should be given another year is, he’s never been given the tools to win. We’ve been trying to rebuild since 2002 (actually, it’s a lot longer then that, but 2002 would be when the “current” rebuilding began) and we were starting from rock bottom. Even this year, when many (including myself) thought the Tigers might get over the hump, the Tigers really don’t have what it takes to win in our division much less securing a playoff spot. It goes to show you when Chris Shelton is your best hitter. While he’s had a solid season, I just don’t see him more then a “good” player on any team that’s in the playoff mix.

And while our rotation has done better then anyone would have expected, it’s still not much better then average. Kyle Farnsworth still leads our team in Runs Saved Above Average (10), and unless Bonderman (7) has a strong finish, Farnsworth could end up the team leader at season end.

I’d just like to see Tram be given a chance with a playoff contending team. If he falls on his face and doesn’t get the job done (a la Larry Bowa), then I’d feel safe about replacing him.

Two managers who come to mind that I would consider putting in Tram’s place would be Davey Johnson (who looks like he’ll be heading up the Orioles again) and Jim Leyland (not sure what his situation is, but he’ll be 61 in December). Both are proven winners and each have World Series rings. One of the readers mentioned Larry Dierker and he’d also be a definite upgrade. I am curious to know why he hasn’t found work since leaving Houston though. He did suffer from a seizure in the dugout, but that was 1999. He went on to have a few more successful years after that.

But outside of securing a handful of proven commodities, I’d like to see Tram in the dugout, and I’d also like to see how he could a handle a more talented team.

I finished David Wells autobiography “Perfect I’m Not.” It really was a great read. Just a good baseball book. And I dare someone to read it and not come away a David Wells fan or (I can hear the groans already) a Yankees Fan. Yes, they have obnoxious fans, but David Wells really paints the team in a favorable light.

I’m also reading John Helyar’s “Lords of the Reams,” which is a fantastic look at the business of baseball. I’m also 200 pages into David McCullough’s tome/biography of Harry Truman. Finally, I started another good read called “Wedding of the Waters” by Peter Bernstein. It’s a look at the construction fo the Erie Canal and it’s effect on our nation.

The Tigers took two today at KC after a tough series in Toronto. The World Champs come to town next for a three game series.

Dierker is doing play-by-play for the Astros now. He is excellent in the booth because he’s very smart and really knows the game. He has indicated in the past, also, that he’s keen on sabermetrics and stuff like that. He’d automatically be much better than Trammell, though I admit that is faint praise.

Posted by Dan on August 15th, 2005 at 12:27 pm

Great game last night guys. I’m a Tigers fan this week. Go Tigers. Yeah!!

Posted by Nick Smith on August 16th, 2005 at 8:59 am

The idea of canning Trammel just a couple of seasons beyond the worst season in Detroit history, boggles the mind. The team has been markedly better the last couple of seasons and anyone expecting more than a .500 ballclub this season is off his/her nut. Talk about wanting to win now! The Tigers just don’t have all the horses they need to win the race. The lack of willingness of players to sign with the Tigers in the Free Agent pool ain’t helping.

Sacking the manager won’t do any good. Get some better players and see what Trammel does with them.

Posted by The Bench Jockey on August 16th, 2005 at 10:42 am

Man, the TIgers blew it last night. This loss alone should cost Tram his job.

Posted by Nick Smith on August 17th, 2005 at 9:06 am

Bench Jockey-
I never said that a new manager will make the Tigers a great team. That’s Dombrowski’s job. I said that Trammell clearly doesn’t know what he’s doing and shows little aptitude for learning on the job. He is a moron. A new manager isn’t going to change the Tigers’ record much, but regardless, Trammell is a crap manager, that’s all. They are better these past two years for two reasons: One, a team with a historically bad record always gets better the next year because that’s the only direction in which a team like that can head and two, Dombrowski’s moves. Trammell doesn’t have a thing to do with it and, in fact, I would argue that he’s costing us a game here and there.

Posted by Dan on August 17th, 2005 at 11:15 am

Tigers Resources
Baseball Historians
Minor League Blogs
Search TigerBlog

Send email
Your email:



Swag of the Moment
coffee mug swag

Show the love! Pick up your very own TigerBlog coffee mug or other item from the TigerBlog Store today!
Historical Baseball Sites
Tiger / Detroit Sites
Reference Sites
General Baseball Sites
Archives by Month
Archives by Category
Powered by