« | »

Phil Coke – Starting Pitcher

Not too long ago, I talked about the Tigers starting pitching.  The winter meetings have come and gone and the Tigers didn’t make a move in that department so it looks like the Phil Coke experiment begins.  Coke was a starter in the Yankees farm system but since he’s been in the major leagues, he’s pitched out of the pen with the exception of his lone start in game 162 for the Tigers in 2010.  Now with Jeremy Bonderman’s departure (i.e. being pushed out), the Tigers are an arm short and it looks like the Tigers are relying on Coke to fill that hole.

Jim Leyland thinks the transition is going to be easy but aren’t things rarely that?  Still, Coke started 77 games in the minors but he’s never had a season where he “just” started.  With Dan Schereth coming up, the Tigers have some wiggle room and what I like best about this move is, Coke isn’t much of a lefty specialist.  In 2010, he had practically no platoon split and as a lefty specialist, your job is to get lefties out.   His career platoon splits are a little better but still, this is a guy who can get righties out too.

Endurance could be a problem and August is Coke’s worst month so far (7.08 ERA in 20 1/3 innings).  The flip side to that is September is one of his better months (3.09 ERA in 32 innings).  Since we’re having fun with splits, Coke is lights out in June.  In 20 2/3 innings, he has a 0.44 ERA and a 0.823 WHIP.  Overall, he’s a little bit worse in the second half then in the first so it’ll be interesting to see how things play out when he’s pitching 150 innings.  Of course he’ll be forced to pace himself better and that could be the big wild card.  If he can accomplish that, we could see a successful transition.

These are interesting times for Tigers fans. If Coke can pitch well as the team’s fifth starter, that would go a long way towards helping the Tigers make the playoffs.  The bad thing is, at least the moment, there’s no good option if the experiment fails.  Andrew Oliver would probably be next in line but I question whether he’s ready.  Should be a fun spring.

I do not see putting Coke as the #3 or #4 starter as any kind of experiment at all.
(Gallaraga is the #5 starter).

Coke was 9-4 2.50 ERA as
a starter for NYY AA club in ’08.

Coke was primarily a starter for most of his baseball life until the Yanks promoted him to the big club and tossed him into the pen as an experiment(and because there was not room for Coke in the rotation at the time).

The Tigers put Coke in the pen last year when many scouts and experts advised the Tigers that Coke was better suited for starting and Coke said he preferred to start like he had most of his baseball life.

Coke would have won a lot more games than Bondo in the rotation last year if you look at his ERA and track record starting.

Tigers were buried in lousy contracts last year so Coke was tossed into the pen.

Posted by SportsFAn7888 on December 10th, 2010 at 12:45 pm

I think it’s a worthy experiment. However, from what the Tigers are saying and relying on, this is more than an experiment – it’s a done deal.

The problem is, and has been for years – what is the backup plan? What’s plan B, some washed up dude or some minor leaguer without enough experience? As usual, the Tigers will leave their butts hanging in the wind. That kind of planning has backfired time and time again. When will DD ever learn?

Posted by billee on December 10th, 2010 at 1:10 pm

This team isn’t going anywhere. The Tigers just don’t get it. You gotta get another big bat and star starting pitcher.

Posted by Dave on December 10th, 2010 at 4:24 pm

Post a comment

Tigers Resources
Baseball Historians
Minor League Blogs
Search TigerBlog

Send email
Your email:



Swag of the Moment
coffee mug swag

Show the love! Pick up your very own TigerBlog coffee mug or other item from the TigerBlog Store today!
Historical Baseball Sites
Tiger / Detroit Sites
Reference Sites
General Baseball Sites
Archives by Month
Archives by Category
Powered by