« | »

Pudge Whines and the Toledo Mudhens Go for the Sweep

I’ve gotten enough email about this and heard enough about it on talk radio to figure out Ivan Rodriguez’s complaints about the team have taken center stage. In addition, Alan Trammell has come under fire for the cliff this team has fallen off of. The two go hand in hand, so they’re worth disecting together.

What Ivan Rodriguez is doing is wrong. Plain and simple. It’s one thing to try to call your team out and inspire them, but what Pudge is trying to do is bring the team down. I know he’s had a rough season, both on and off the field, but what he’s done since the Farnsworth trade (openly criticize teammates and his coaches) is inexcusable. More so because he can’t even back up what he’s talking about. Maybe when he says the team sucks, he should be looking in the mirror when he says it, because his season hasn’t gone as well as season’s past.

He does lead the team in hitting, but he has a grand total of 49 RBIs. And this is for a guy who’s hacking at anything. Eight more strikeouts and he has a career best, and his .759 OPS is his worst in over a decade. The only thing that’s improved of late is his defense. To date, he has 12 Fielding Runs Above Average, which is his best since 2001. Three more and he’ll have his best fielding season since 1999.

Not to mention how guys like Brandon Inge and Craig Monroe, who have been with the team all season (really the only regular starters besides Pudge who hasn’t missed some kind of substantial time or gotten benched), must feel when they’re told by a future Hall of Famer that they suck. I doubt if they appreciate being told they don’t play the right way.

So, either Pudge is trying to get Tram out (and he’s going about it in a poor way) or he’s trying to get out of Detroit. I think it’s the later, but he has to remember that two years ago, nobody wanted him. We were his only suitors. And now he’s biting the hand that’s fed him.

Which brings me to Tram. I still feel, because of some misguided loyalty to what he did for the team in the 1980s, that he should be given one more year. He’ll have to contend with Pudge because I doubt if we’ll be able to unload him. I think that will be as big of a test as any. I think managment has to address the team’s needs (starting pitching and a quality left handed bat) and give Tram the tools to win. Let him fail without excuses.

Toledo is playing game three of their playoff series with the Indianoplis Indians. They’re up 2-0 and a win tonight will give them the Governor’s Cup. Unfortunately there’s a rain delay, so we might have to wait another night.

Agree with your comments Brian. Pudge’s behavior is reprehensible. Trammell deserves one more year, one more shot. Let’s hope he gets it.

Posted by Cameron on September 15th, 2005 at 9:53 pm

“Leading the team in batting”… I hadn’t noticed that. I’ll be including it in a column, probably later today… Thanks, Brian.

Posted by jeff k on September 16th, 2005 at 9:47 am

In the past we’ve discussed the fact that you don’t have any real reasons for your loyalty to Trammell, and you again mention here that it is “misguided”. Of course it is. I’ll go on the record to say that Trammell absolutely does NOT deserve one more year. He is not a good manager. I have no idea why I’m the only one who seems to have noticed.

Posted by Dan on September 19th, 2005 at 11:36 am

Trammell should have been lead out of the stadium in handcuffs on many occasions this year. Prime example of his inept managing was in today’s Free Press. enjoy…

Representing the potential tying run, Granderson singled with one out in the ninth, then stood on first as Craig Monroe faced closer Francisco Rodriguez with two out.

Monroe got the count to 3-0, received the green light with Magglio Ordonez on deck, swung — and popped up.

The Angels won three of four in the series and kept their two-game lead in the American League West. Monroe, who made his first start of the season in the No. 3 spot, walked off the field holding the bat over his head with two hands.

In the clubhouse, he repeatedly watched a tape of the final pitch, said he got the fastball he sought, then added, “I liked that swing. I just missed it. It was the moment you live for.”

Manager Alan Trammell regularly lets his hitters swing on 3-0. He said of turning Monroe loose with Ordonez on deck, “Regardless of who’s hitting behind you, two outs is the time to let somebody swing 3-0 and not put it on the next guy, because then it starts 0-0. You’re in the favorable count.”

That logic is garbage and is beyond getting old. I could care less what Trammell did for us in the 80s. he needs to leave.

Posted by Michael on September 19th, 2005 at 11:46 am

Tigers Resources
Baseball Historians
Minor League Blogs
Search TigerBlog

Send email
Your email:



Swag of the Moment
coffee mug swag

Show the love! Pick up your very own TigerBlog coffee mug or other item from the TigerBlog Store today!
Historical Baseball Sites
Tiger / Detroit Sites
Reference Sites
General Baseball Sites
Archives by Month
Archives by Category
Powered by